AndyH
May 25 2004, 12:17 PM
Is the 15 day notice required in the case of an incorporated 1 life DB plan that employs only the owner?
Clearly an "owner-employee" plan is exempt but our legal people are hesitant to extend this to a corporation due to some concern over some part of regulation 2510.3-3(b).
Has anybody looked at this?
I know the EOB says that plans eligible for 5500-EZ are exempt and the EZ instructions clearly allow such filing by a 1 life owner employee corporation so that is one bullet in my gun. I'm looking for more ammunition. Thanks for any help.
David MacLennan
May 25 2004, 12:28 PM
What part of the regs are they concerned about? Paragraph c(1) clearly states that where a corporation is wholly owned by the individual, or the individual and the spouse, then they are not employees under Title I.
AndyH
May 25 2004, 01:01 PM
The reservation is the specific reference in Q&A 3 which which refers to employees "as described in 2510.3-3(b)"
And 3(b) describes plans without employees and gives examples of unincorporated businesses and keogh plans.
Not until you get to 3© does this get extended to "...or business, whether incorporated or unincorporated"
Clearly this is a conservative interpretation but it is from an experienced ERISA attorney and I am trying to overcome it with facts.
David MacLennan
May 25 2004, 01:26 PM
Paragraph c states that it applies to the entire section. But I see your point now - the ERISA attorney is saying the Q&A 3 refers to paragraph b which must be viewed apart from any other paragraphs. That is not just conservative, in my opinion it goes to being unreasonable in the extreme. Ammunition: "if you need to justify your existence, please do it in some other way" (just kidding - everyone is entitled to their opinion!).
AndyH
May 25 2004, 02:18 PM
QUOTE
That is not just conservative, in my opinion it goes to being unreasonable in the extreme.
A lesser person I may have said that to!
Thank you for the comments and the sympathetic ear.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.