Tom ---
If your current legal counsel is giving "vague information" and/or if you have lost confidence in her/him, get yourself competent experienced ESOP counsel who knows the rules and is able to give you definitive advice.
You're the client....you should expect and demand more from counsel than "vague" advice on such important matters.
There are many good ESOP lawyers out there who would welcome a new ESOP company client. Check with The ESOP Association (
www.esopassociation.org) and the National Center for Employee Ownership (
www.nceo.org) for recommendations.